Tuesday, June 5, 2012

A possible plan for an edition in ten volumes

I have now had a chance to do a lot of the work of estimating just how many pages we are dealing with, just how marginal and fragmentary some of the fragments and variants are, etc., and have been laying out tentative volumes. My working assumption at this stage, based on the little feedback I've received, is that there is indeed a desire for a fairly complete edition, but perhaps not such a deep scholarly desire that every fragment and variant needs to make it into a print edition. For the moment, I'm also banishing the thought that we'll run into insurmountable permissions issues regarding anything absolutely essential. And, not having been contradicted by anyone, I'm still assuming that the focus on presenting Bakunin's work, as opposed to, for example, documenting key conversations of which he was a part, is presently the one that fills the largest gap in the published materials. So, based on those assumptions, it looks like an edition of The Collected Works of Bakunin might logically break down into ten volumes, chronologically order, roughly like this:
  1. Early writings and correspondence: 1837-1851 
  2. Writings: 1860-1867 
  3. Writings: 1868-1869 
  4. Writings: 1870-1871 
  5. "The Knouto-Germanic Empire & the Social Revolution:" 1870-1871 
  6. "Against Mazzini" & other writings: 1871 
  7. "Statism and Anarchy" & other writings: 1872-1876 
  8. Correspondence 
  9. Correspondence 
  10. Correspondence, bibliography, index, miscellany
I see no reason to tie our publishing schedule to the chronological order, since it makes at least as much sense to work from general, familar, and/or currently topical to specific, unfamiliar, and of primarily historical interest. But the proposed division does respect some fairly natural divisions in Bakunin's career.

Getting to this stage of planning is a fairly significant relief, given the fragmentary nature of Bakunin's work. But perhaps what seems like a triumph of organization to me looks different to other potential users of the work, so, once again, I would welcome any and all feedback.

3 comments:

  1. Sounds like it'll be an interesting project.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Labor Activist from TexasJune 17, 2012 at 6:23 PM

    I would just like to say that you kick ass, Shawn.

    I heard about a collected Bakunin works anthology some time ago in an AK Press catalog. The idea got my excited, but I never heard more about it. The only exposure to Bakunin I've had has been the collection put together by Black Rose Books and edited by Sam Dolgoff. That and stuff online, which is mostly in the book anyway. It was formative to my political outlook. The idea of having ten volumes would be awesome.

    I just wish I knew French or German, so I could help in some way. This is invaluable work!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I believe Editions Champ Libre (Paris, France) published his complete works in five volumes in the 1970s.

    ReplyDelete